Anon. (Sign in or Register)

Reply Printable  
Page 1 of 1.

Topic: Fat vs Carbs-
dandysxm, Oct 4 2008 9:18 am171 words

Sorry to hijack your thread but it won't let me start a new one for some reason.

Which is better: ( I want/need to loose ~40lbs)
to be under the daily calorie/fat numbers and right on for carbs
or
to be right on with calorie/fat numbers and over for carbs

My typical (hopefully) daily menu is
breakfast - cereal w/ 1% milk, 8oz V8
lunch - Yoplait Light, glucerna meal bar or shake
snack - glucerna snack shake or bar
dinner - healthychoice dinner

My numbers look like this

Actual Target
Calories 1,000 1300
Calories from Fat 150 260 - 450
Total Fat 17 g 29 - 51g
Saturated Fat 4 g <= 14g
Cholesterol 50 mg < 300mg
Sodium 1,330 mg < 2400mg
Total Carbohydrate 190 g 163 - 195g
Dietary Fiber 16 g >= 25g
Protein 50 g 49 - 75g
Vitamin A * *
Vitamin C 170% 100%
Calcium 70% 100%
Iron 170% 100%

If I adjust/add items to get the calories/fat numbers within range, the carb numbers go into the "significantly above" range. Is there anything higher in calorie/fat that isn't high in carbs?

You regulars here rock
Thanks
dan

0 star rating
 

LynnGr, Oct 3 2008 6:35 pm189 words

Hi Dan. I'm happy to share my suggestions with you, but you'll get the best information if you talk with a registered dietitian who is also a certified diabetes educator. Usually hospitals have RDs who work with you on an outpatient basis, and often physicians refer to RDs in the community as well. Ask your doctor for a referral and I'm sure you'll find it helpful.

There really isn't a set answer to your question. Obviously it's best to meet your calorie, fat, AND carbohydrate targets, but as you found it's not as simple as it sounds! You might have better success if you chose whole foods for at least some of your meals and snacks instead of relying on convenience foods. For example, if you choose a salad with grilled chicken and lots of vegetables for lunch you can keep the calories and carbohydrate content low.

Also, are you checking your blood sugar levels? That will give you the best information about how effective your meal plan is in helping you reach your goals. I'm sure some of the others on the message boards will also have suggestions.

 

Page 1 of 1.

Moderators:

robinjl1, smeredit13, Deb, BruceDCFL, mschoenbach, ronluks, TomPerry, Tom Christie, FOLChrista, LynnGr, ShelleyN, tinap1, sherri01, aarnold, christined

Similar topics
 TopicsViewsPosts        Last reply 
Topic Do you use 100-calorie snack pack foods?

LynnGr
Aug 28 2008 5:00 pm
1,0913
LynnGr
Sep 1 2008 3:35 pm
 
Topic Replacing meal with a shake

San_Diego_Sailor
Sep 22 2008 12:40 pm
1,0852
ShelleyN
Sep 22 2008 3:48 pm
 
Topic Sticking to a daily or weekly exercise plan

tinap1
Dec 10 2008 11:49 am
1,2002
BoredAlaskan
Dec 10 2008 7:03 pm
 
Topic Power snack suggestions

tinap1
Feb 12 2009 12:53 pm
4031  
Topic Cutting 100 calories a day

tinap1
Mar 19 2009 9:12 am
2801  

Go to forum Return to the top of the page

 
Nov 20 2009 9:08 pm

Statistics: 8 people online; 43,746 users; 1,820 posts; 128,942 words


Powered by Active Data Online Discussion Board v5.2 © 2007